Hugging the Canadian border closely, and a short drive away from Niagara Falls, Buffalo is considered to be the ‘City of Good Neighbors’. If you’re looking for a place to stay during your trip, then these top Airbnb Buffalo, NY rentals will have you covered.
The large city in New York state is known for its cleanliness, tasty cuisine, and bustling nightlife (which can often extend to sunrise).
Not only is the city rich in history and architectural beauty, but it also offers a large number of parks and outdoor areas for travelers who enjoy kicking back and enjoying nature. The first step in enjoying what this fantastic city has to offer is to pick a spot to stay.
Imagine a travel destination that smells of spicy chicken wings, sounds like sports fans cheering, and looks like a bustling city located on a creek. Buffalo is a top travel destination for several reasons. To find out which of these reasons is your favorite – browse these vacation rentals in Buffalo, NY.
Airbnb Buffalo: Quick Breakdown of Buffalo Vacation Rentals
This list is fairly extensive and covers a variety of accommodation options. However, if you want a quick overview of the best, then you can begin here.
- Best Overall Vacation Rental in Buffalo – Elmwood Village Downstairs Suite
- Best Family Apartment in Buffalo – Historic Home in The Elmwood Village with a HEPA Air Purifier and Intellipure
- Best Luxury Buffalo Vacation Rental – Architecturally Amazing Victorian 7 bedroom, 7 bathroom Grand Victoria
- Best Affordable Airbnb in Buffalo, NY – Heart of Elmwood
- Best Second-Floor Apartment in Buffalo – Charming Apartment with Period Details in a Hip Neighborhood
I’ve also included several inspiring travel videos about Buffalo and nearby surroundings to get your travel tastebuds salivating. Be sure to watch these videos and take note of their tips and suggestions for some unique and fun ideas!
Note: Due to the closure of the Airbnb Associates program, some of the properties listed have been changed to other booking platforms (which can have lower rates and less cleaning/service fees!
Best Areas To Stay in Buffalo Vacation Rental
It can be overwhelming trying to decide where to stay in a city if you’ve never been there before. How do you know which areas are hip and which to avoid? Before we dive into my list of the top 17 Buffalo, NY, vacation rentals on Airbnb, here are some of the best areas to keep on your radar.
- Elmwood Village: A vibrant and trendy area full of bars, restaurants, and activity. The tree-lined area is popular for families, farmer’s markets, and artisanal entrepreneurs selling their products.
- Central Park: Known to be family-friendly and conveniently located, Central Park’s most popular road is Hertel Avenue, which is home to several attractions and fresh entertainment venues, offering the perfect mix of old and new.
- Allentown: Loved for its artistic flair, Allentown is a hub of inspiration and creativity. Expect galleries, restaurants, and eccentric characters when walking the streets of this district.
- West Side: West Side offers a melting pot of cultures as the international influence is made apparent. As a result, the food is diverse, the entrepreneurial attitude is inspiring, and the mood is friendly.
- Parkside: Just east of Delaware Park, Parkside offers some peace and quiet from the city’s hustle and bustle without completely removing you. The classic American neighborhood has a few hidden gems and is a great spot to stay.
The 20 Best Airbnb Buffalo & Vacation Rentals
Alright, now let’s dive a bit deeper into each listing! Browse this diverse and dynamic list of options and pick the one that best suits your taste and budget.
1) Elmwood Village Downstairs Suite
Location: Elmwood Village
Price: $120+ USD per night
https://www.vrbo.com/7152509ha
Elmwood Village is arguably the most happening area in Buffalo, and my choice for the best overall Buffalo vacation rental is right in the heart of the village. This compact one bedroom downstairs suite is ideal for a solo stay in the city or a couples vacation, and is equipped with elegant interiors, a bathroom, a large living and dining area and a bedroom with a king bed. With both air conditioning and heating, the five-star star is close to many top areas of Buffalo and lots of cafes, restaurants, bars and shops. Niagara Falls is just 30 minutes away.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Adrian and Ashlee were incredible hosts! If we had a question or issue with anything, they would immediately respond and go to extra lengths to make sure we had what we needed. The apartment itself was perfect for my husband and I for our two-day stay. We wished we had booked for longer! The bed is a King and one of the most comfortable beds I’ve ever slept on in a VRBO rental. The location was literally 15-20 minutes away from everywhere we had planned to go, and there seemed to be tons of coffee shops and pubs within walkable distance from the apt. We will come back!” – Lisa
Credit: VRBO
2) Historic Home in The Elmwood Village with a HEPA Air Purifier and Intellipure
Location: Elmwood Village
Price: $1200+ USD per night
This historic family home is a gem of Buffalo and located in the buzzing neighborhood of Elmwood Village. The perfect location to make fond family memories, this stunning property boasts five bedrooms, a home gym, a front porch and back patio. The high end home is eco-friendly and “green”, with non toxic cleaning supplies throughout. Downtown is just a few miles away, and Buffalo State College is less than a mile. From here, it’s no more than 30 minutes to world famous landmark Niagara Falls.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “I loved this property so much that I don’t want other people to book it so it’s available for me to come back! Haha! Everything was lovely in every way. The home is beautiful, the porch is blissful, location is ideal, and bunnies hop and play in the front yard!! Two thumbs up :)” – Christina
Credit: VRBO
3) Architecturally Amazing Victorian 7 bedroom, 7 bathroom Grand Victoria
Location: Elmwood Village
Price: $650+ USD per night
Boasting rave reviews on other home share platforms, this stunning Victorian home is a sight for sore eyes. The seven bedroom and bathroom home spans a generous 6000 square feet, and its interiors are regal with beautiful attention to detail. This palatial home’s three levels have all been lovingly restored, and the home is located in the popular Elmwood Village, close to many of Buffalo’s best restaurants, malls and the Buffalo Zoo.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Credit: VRBO
4) Urban Modern Design Home in Elmwood Village
Location: Elmwood Village
Airbnb Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $188+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/plus/25814062
This carefully designed space offers the ultimate private getaway for relaxation. It won’t be long before the beautifully combined hardwood, brick, and textured furniture becomes a second home, and you’ll have a hard-pressed job leaving.
The property can accommodate eight guests, making it an ideal option for large families and groups of friends. The home offers lots of natural light, a laundry room, and even a travel crib and highchair. Located within walking distance to shops, restaurants, breweries, and more, this Elmwood village home offers the best of all worlds.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Beautiful home, amazing location. Steps to great food and shops. The owners have thoughtfully designed the home and it’s comfortable and welcoming. They are great at communicating and we have a lovely time at this property!”
5) Perfect Location Elmwood Single Family Home w/King Master
Location: Elmwood Village
Airbnb Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $245+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/plus/25193818
This cute cottage may be located in a quiet street, but it is also only a couple of blocks from a wide choice of shops, restaurants, and bars. When you’re not out exploring the amazing things to do in the city, you can enjoy this spot’s two outdoor spaces (which are particularly magical in summer).
The cottage has had special mention made of its comfortable beds and helpful host, who considers welcoming guests one of his passions.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “We had a great time! The house was perfect! The beds were extremely comfortable and I’m pretty picky about the bed I sleep in. Domenic and his team were extremely helpful and were excellent communicators. I highly recommend staying here!”
6) Upper Level Apartment in Revitalized Historical Home
Location: Parkside
Airbnb Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $175+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/plus/26195516
“Clean” and “pristine” are two words that perfectly describe this 5-star apartment. Guests enjoy a private entrance to the eclectically designed apartment, which perfectly blends a modern mood with a historic building.
Located in the beautiful neighborhood of Parkside, this stunning home offers a glimpse into the past. The hardwood flooring and covered canopy view balcony paired with stylish finishings is enough to make any traveler fall in love with the home.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This Airbnb was PERFECT! It’s so gorgeous and cozy, the pictures don’t do it justice. The owners were so welcoming and accommodating. They had drinks in the fridge, extra toiletries in the bathroom and muffins with fruit set up for us to snack on. Anything we needed they were quick to respond. It was such an awesome stay!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED”
7) Heart of Elmwood
Location: Elmwood Village
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $60+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/16429711
This one-bedroom apartment in the center of Elmwood Village is the perfect choice for travelers wanting to be in the middle of the action without compromising comfort. Despite being in a busy area, the cozy spot isn’t noisy. It also offers highly coveted parking spots for visitors.
The entire apartment is available for booking, and each room is decorated in a warm and stylish manner. Guests will immediately feel welcome after stepping across the threshold.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This apartment is beautiful, comfortable, and in a perfect location! We had a wonderful overnight here before heading up to Niagara Falls for the day. We will definitely book again if ever in Buffalo!!”
8) Charming Apartment with Period Details in a Hip Neighborhood
Location: Lakeview
Airbnb Plus: Yes
Superhost: Yes
Price: $118+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/plus/22243927
How do you decide on the biggest selling point of this apartment when it is full of charm, has a quaint front terrace, and an expansive view of the surrounding neighborhood? This stylish apartment is on the West Side and is within walking distance to several trendy entertainment spots.
It’s quite a challenge to balance modern style with old-school comfort, but this apartment has made the achievement look effortless. If you’re visiting Buffalo in a group of four, then this is a top pick for sure!
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Best AirBnB I’ve ever stayed in! It has everything you need, feels like home and yet so stylish. The most comfortable bed I’ve ever slept in. Honestly didn’t even want to leave the flat. Skip the hotel. Come here. Promise you will not regret it!”
9) Victorian 1920’s Era Beauty (Elmwood Village)
Location: Elmwood Village
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: No
Price: $82+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/6038162
You and an additional six guests can enjoy the entire graceful Victorian home that boasts a large kitchen, jacuzzi bath, and relaxing porch area (which is perfect for evening drinks). If you’re looking for lots of space and a home away from home – then this is it.
The brown, wooden interiors create a warm and inviting atmosphere. With an indoor fireplace, heating, and consistent WiFi, the home in Elmwood Village is a great place to set up your laptop if the “pleasure” part of your trip doubles up with “work”.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This place is absolutely stunning – so much space and all decorated beautifully. We were able to pretend we were in a different, bygone era – or even a classic mystery – for a few days.”
10) College Cottage: Private Apt in Trendy Allentown
Location: Allentown
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $58+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/20535891
If you’re on a budget and looking for a low-maintenance place to unwind, then this apartment in Allentown is a great option. The booking comes with a private bedroom upstairs and offers a comfortable queen-sized bed to relax after a fun day out exploring.
In addition, there’s a fully equipped kitchen, bathroom, and front porch available to enjoy. If you have any questions or needs during your stay, then step downstairs and chat with your host (and his friendly dog).
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Had the pleasure of staying with Nino and in addition to his place being in a fantastic location, check in, communication, and hospitality are all top class. Also, a stay here is a guarantee for good people and good conversation if you’re predisposed to interacting with your host… Cannot recommend highly enough. Thanks again, Nino!!”
11) The Mulberry on Crescent
Location: Parkside
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: No
Price: $62+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/21475576
This apartment, located on the second floor of the home, offers two sleeping areas, a living room, a full bathroom, and a fully equipped kitchen. But that’s not all. It also provides a wonderful porch area that has a stunning street view.
The apartment is a stone’s throw away from hip and happening restaurants, pubs, and boutiques in Elmwood Avenue. A few steps away from other key attractions, including Albright-Knox Art Gallery and the local farmer’s market.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This spot is a gem. Extremely comfortable and clean. It sets the perfect ambiance. I would highly recommend it to anyone. Not to mention that the pricing is extremely reasonable.”
12) Modern Carriage House with Garage Parking
Location: Lakeview
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $90+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/17701778
This modern house comes with several luxuries that will leave you feeling overjoyed that you made this booking your vacation rental spot. Buffalo, NY, is full of wonderful attractions, and this spot is close to many of them, including the canalside.
The home is cozy and stylish, in an under-stated way and without trying too hard. The place features a newly-renovated kitchen, an outdoor courtyard, and – as it mentions in the description – a garage parking.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Eliza’s place is FANTASTIC! It is even better than the pictures. The garage was an added bonus and made parking very easy. I visited Niagara Falls and Lake Erie and both were very close. There are lots of yummy eateries around and best of all even my dog (who usually gets very anxious in new spaces) felt right at home! The windows let in a lot of light and the decor was amazing. I would definitely stay again!”
13) Modern West Side Apartment
Location: Lower West Side
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $70+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/20542689
Guests have access to the whole apartment, with the host staying on the property, ready to answer any questions. The condo is slick, clean, and comfortable, with everything that you need for a pleasant stay.
Special notes have been made about the cleanliness of the space and the excellent communication of the host. If you’re looking for a spot that is fully equipped, and snug, as well as close to buzzing entertainment spots, then this is a winner.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “A cozy apartment that’s convenient to travel from to other popular areas. The location is really good if you want to go downtown, Elmwood village, or check out the Niagara Falls area. It’s also really close to a beautiful park which was a nice treat!”
14) Buffalo’s Allentown Area Apartment
Location: Allentown
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $67+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/1633607
Everyone loves a newly furnished apartment that offers its own private entrance. This apartment located in the trendy district of Allentown is a great place to stay as a pair and can add a bed for a third guest.
The vaulted ceiling and private porch add extra charm to the space, with plenty of vibrant pubs and restaurants in the area. As an added bonus, the neighbors are known to be particularly friendly, so be sure to smile and wave.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Staying here was cozy and easy! Thomas offers detailed and quick communication about check in, check out, etc. so I never had any questions or worries. The space had all the amenities we needed including a usable kitchen, and was walking distance from food, shops, and cafes. I would visit again and recommend.”
15) Parkside Suite in Desired Urban Neighborhood
Location: Parkside
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $60+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/25743363
Offering a charming blend of historical elegance with comfort and ease, this spot in Parkside is the perfect break from the busy city without venturing too far. Well-behaved pets are welcome, and there is a pool available to cool down in the summer months.
The accommodation is near a park, key attractions, and public transportation. This spot proves that simplicity is very effective and that there’s no need to break the bank in order to have comfort.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “We greatly enjoyed all the historic charm of this guest suite. It was conveniently located, a short Uber ride to most bars and restaurants. Hosts were very communicative and made the whole check-in a breeze. We would definitely stay here again!”
16) LarkinVille Loft
Location: South Ellicott
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $73+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/36963255
This easy-going simple loft offers an open-plan kitchen and living room space, which is great for socializing. The large windows allow for a lot of natural light, and the dark hardwood floors offer a warm mood.
The loft features one bedroom with a queen-size bed and a sofa, which doubles up as a second bed when pulled out. The location is not necessarily in the middle of the action, but there are local restaurants and entertainment venues surrounding the loft.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This place is great! The apartment is decked out with all kinds of amenities that make you feel at home. It’s easily accessible to downtown and to the falls. There’s a really cool pizza/craft beer spot right across the street, which is a bonus. I would recommend this place for anyone traveling to Buffalo! Perfect for 2 people :)”
17) Castle Oasis – 5 Star Clean & Triple Sanitized
Location: Front Park
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $143+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/19333173
If you’re looking for space and convenience, then this option is a great choice. The home can accommodate six guests with large open spaces to allow you to relax and enjoy your vacation. The bustling area of Downtown Buffalo is nearby, with key attractions such as Front Park and Community Beer Works.
The spacious home and green grounds will have your mood feeling lightened in no time. The ‘Castle’ is the perfect place to enjoy a city break and create wonderful memories.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “We had a great experience!! Place was very clean and they had a photo of us from Airbnb on a photo frame for us as we walk in. The host was welcoming and they gave a lot of advice on places to go. We look forward to coming again.”
18) Cute Studio Apartment with Private Back Entrance
Location: Lower West Side
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $56+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/35636352
This small, studio apartment is simple yet effective. It has everything that you need for a memorable stay in Buffalo. With the West Side Bazaar less than a mile away, and other main Buffalo tourist attractions only a touch further, you’ll find yourself spending very little time in the flat at all.
The back studio apartment has a private entrance and is a close walk to Allentown. There is a queen-size bed for two guests, with a futon for an additional visitor if needed. If you’re visiting during Buffalo’s colder months, then you can also light up the fireplace and switch on the record player.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “Stephanie’s space was perfect for me & my pup. Walking distance to the Five Points neighborhood, a great backyard & a perfect little space. We were very happy & hope to come back!”
19) Elmwood Village Private Suite
Location: Bryant
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $50+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/24010373
Guests can enjoy this entire apartment in Elmwood Village, located only a short walk from the funky area of Allentown. The entire third floor is dedicated to visitors, with a private ensuite bedroom and bathroom.
The small but comfortable space is perfectly suited for couples, students, and single travelers – but is not recommended for anyone who has a fear of heights.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “I am a repeat stayer at Katie’s place! Super cozy and a great location. Katie is super quick to respond, also. 10/10 would recommend!”
20) New: Steps from Downtown, Modern Apt w/ King Bed
Location: Allentown
Airbnb Plus: No
Superhost: Yes
Price: $85+ USD per night
https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/33185834
What better spot to finish off the list than this new, modern apartment nestled in the historic area of Allentown. The spacious lower apartment is within walking distance to some of the most eclectic spots in the area.
The clean and stylish space is both inviting and warm, suggesting a wonderful mood of relaxation and enjoyment.
View Photos, Read Reviews & Check Availability
Guest Review: “This is one of the top AirBNB places I’ve stayed in. Very cozy and has everything you need to have a great trip. Kenneth answered precisely and helped whenever I needed help. Would recommend to my friends.”
Best Buffalo Day Tours / Buffalo Airbnb Experiences
Now that you’ve picked your favorite Airbnb, you can be certain that you’ll have a comfortable spot to lay your head each night. Here are a few day trips and tours around the Buffalo area to help decide how to spend the day.
History Ride – Best of Buffalo by Bike
“The History Ride brings the city’s past to life through unforgettable stories, songs, humor, and local insight.
Learn about Buffalo’s heavy hitters – from wild Erie Canal stories to the Pan American Exposition. We’ll also learn about some of Buffalo’s lesser-known aspects including the city’s significance to the civil rights and labor movements.
https://www.airbnb.com/experiences/527833
Price: From $46+ USD
Renaissance Ride Food Bike Tour
“Buffalo is back on the rise thanks to a unique small businesses community and citizen activists. Sample some of the best food hotspots, including a globally-sourced coffee shop, a worker-owned bakery, and an international food market run by refugees.
Savor the flavors while learning about the city’s history of immigration and its connection to its current immigrant communities. We’ll also hear about groundbreaking urban gardening initiatives, grassroots organizing, and the community heroes who are leading the city’s resurgence.”
https://www.airbnb.com/experiences/528357
Price: From $70+ USD
Genesee Country Village & Museum Entry Ticket
“Go back in time to 19th Century America at New York State’s Largest Living History Museum. Through interactive programs, events, and exhibits, discover the history of New York State.”
Price: From $18+ USD
Am I Missing Any Top-Notch Buffalo Airbnbs?
This comprehensive list of Airbnbs includes some of the best-rated vacation rentals in Buffalo, NY – but there may be a few missing. If you’ve visited the area and stumbled across a hidden gem on Airbnb, please do reach out so that we can add it to the list!
Explore the Rest of the Northern States
You could easily get lost in the multitude of fun guides and suggested topics on my site. If you’re enthusiastic about this Buffalo, NY, Airbnb post, then the following articles may be of specific interest to you.
- Top 17 stunning glamping New York places for your bucket list
- The 16 best Brooklyn Airbnbs for the coolest New York experience
- The 99 Best New York quotes to transport you to the Big Apple
- The 20 best music festivals in New York to experience before you die
- The 20 coolest & best Airbnbs in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
- The 16 coolest & best Airbnb Burlington, Vermont vacation rentals
- 75+ Awesome quotes about Seattle perfect for a rainy day
- 17 Amazing Airbnbs in Portland, Maine for an ideal getaway
- The 15 best New England glamping locations for a northeastern getaway
- Top 14 music festivals in Oregon to experience before you die
- The 21 Best Airbnbs in Portland to rest, rejuvenate & explore
Final Thoughts on Buffalo Airbnbs
As the second-largest city in New York state, Buffalo has no shortage of Airbnb rentals to choose from. Whether you’re on a budget and looking for a small, cozy room or a luxurious guest house all to yourself – you’re in for a treat.
If you’re feeling extra adventurous, you can also hop over the Canadian border and check out some of the epic Canadian music festivals that are hosted throughout the year.
Trackbacks & Pingbacks
[…] THE 17 COOLEST & BEST AIRBNB BUFFALO NY VACATION RENTALS […]
Comments are closed.